8 Scary Digital Marketing Mistakes

by Lindsey Winsemius - Posted 6 years ago

Scary Digital Marketing Mistakes (and how to avoid them)

updated 10/18/2017


Do you celebrate Halloween? If you do, you are in good company. Americans are expected to spend $9.1 billion this year on Halloween costumes, candy, parties, and decor, up from $7 billion when I first published this article in 2013.

I love Halloween. And while I am getting into the spirit for this fun-filled holiday, let's talk about what scares us at ApogeeINVENT:  Ugly websites, spammy email campaigns, and bad content are just a few things that come to mind. 

Scaring your friends with creepy costumes and tricks is great. Scaring your customers is not so great. The following are some of the most common scary mistakes businesses make in the their Digital Marketing. Here is how you can avoid these scary mistakes, both on Halloween and after.


8 Scary Digital Marketing Mistakes and How to Avoid Them:

1. Dead Silence. 

Customers expect businesses to be available and quick to respond on blogs and through social media.  One of the worst mistakes you can make as a company is to play dead when a customer interacts with you on the Internet. 

78% of people who complain to a brand via Twitter expect a response within an hour. (Source: Lithium)  That is up from only 25% in 2013. That is a huge jump in expecting customer service through social media. 

How to avoid this mistake:

Are you monitoring your brand on social sites? Not just responding to comments on your page, but actually searching for mentions of your business? 96% of the people that discuss brands online do not follow those brands’ owned profiles (Source: Brandwatch), so it is up to you to find out what is being said and respond accordingly. Don't scare your customers away with dead silence, but treat them to helpful, fast feedback.

2. Unwanted Haunting. 

Do you haunt your customers through numerous mediums and numerous times a day? Don't scare customers away by being a nuisance. Too many daily social media updates or emails can be your customer's worst nightmare.  The more posts per day, the less engagement -- when a brand posts twice a day, those posts only receive 57% of the likes and 78% of the comments per post. (Source:Track Social ) 

How to avoid this mistake:

Be mindful of your publishing frequency on Facebook, and start testing with your own page to see what frequency is right for your community. Send only solicited, useful, and well-timed content to your subscribers and fans to keep them around. Make it easy for people to unsubscribe. If they aren't happy to receive your content, you probably don't want them on your mailing list anyway. AND, you certainly don't want people reporting your emails and hurting your deliverability.

3. Freaky Subjects. 

If you use email marketing (and you should!), avoid email subjects that will look like spam.  61% of emails received at professional email accounts are non-essential. (Source: Mimecast ) Inboxes are overflowing with marketing email, and email clients are getting more and more strict about cracking down on spam.

Here are a few subject lines to avoid if you want to stay out of spam filters and improve your email deliverability rates: 

  • Don't use both an ! and ? in the same subject.
  • Never say "urgent reply needed", no matter how urgent it might be.
  • Avoid using a percentage over 100%
  • Don't ever get excited about Oprah (I like Oprah! = spam). Yes, this is both funny and true
  • Asking people if they want something or have something in the subject triggers spam filters. "Do you need XYZ?"
  • Including the phrase "will help" in your subject line is bad.
How to avoid this mistake:

How to make sure your emails are making it into inboxes, and not getting marked as spam once they are there?

Use personalization, proper timing, and offers valuable to the recipient to break through the clutter and be seen. Make unsubscribing easy, and send only the kind of content you've promised.

4. Tricks Instead of Treats. 

Are you handing out dental floss when they are looking for candy? There is nothing worse than getting information you don't need or want from a source you thought was going to give you something useful. 

How to avoid this mistake:

If you promise industry tips, don't send out product information. Don't trick your audience when they are looking for a treat. Email the content that was promised, and post useful information that is related to your industry for your fans. Otherwise, they might skip over your business in the future and look elsewhere for the treat they expect.

5. Inescapable Maze. 

Is your website a maze that your visitors must navigate to find what they want? While a corn maze might be exciting, nobody wants to spend an hour looking for information on the web. Make sure your website is well-designed so users can quickly find the information they are looking for. 

How to avoid this mistake:

It is important to give visitors clear and obvious directions on where they should go. Want a free trial - click here. Want to contact us? Fill out this form. Make your navigation bar visible, simple, and include the main pages of your site. 

Distracting but necessary items, like privacy policies and terms, are best left to the bottom navigation (footer) of your site. Use anchor text to send users to the correct part of a page so they don't have to scroll. Consider using dedicated landing pages for important offers so users are focused on a single call-to-action.

Finding the item or information they were searching for in the first place is a priority, and if they can't immediately see how to get to the information they want, a user is likely to leave the site and look elsewhere. 

6. Shape Changing. 

From Dracula turning into a bat, to the man who becomes werewolf, shape changing can be frightening. Your customers will think so, too. 

Are you sending mixed messages through your marketing? Do you misrepresent yourself on your website, through social media, or through your blog? Nothing will send your customers running more quickly than perceived lies or misinformation. 

How to avoid this mistake:

Be honest, be transparent, and let your customers get to know you. 

Even content practices that use techniques like click-baiting will hurt you. Not only will it affect your advertising, you will be risking your reputation. Getting customers through honest information and valuable content will not just attract them, it will keep them coming back and build a good online reputation. 

7. Criminal Insanity. 

When I first wrote this article in 2013, the insanity I was referring to was businesses neglecting to use the Internet as part of their marketing efforts. In 2017, most businesses understand the value of the Internet, even if they do underutilize it.

In 2017, I want to talk about mobile. 85% of mobile advertisers think they’re providing a positive experience; only 47% of users agree. (Unlockd) The majority of brands are still failing their mobile users. Worse still, most of them don’t even realize they’re doing it but you can guarantee their visitors do. Bloated sites, sloppy code, and aggressive advertising are just a few of the bad habits many sites are still guilty of – and we should all know better by now.



More people are browsing, researching, and buying on mobile devices than on desktops. A poorly designed mobile site will cost you customers. And that would be just criminal.


How to avoid this mistake: 
Get a well-designed replicated website that is perfect for mobile users. Already have a website? Test it using Google's Mobile-Friendly test. And don't forget to design mobile-friendly emails.

8.    Monstrously Hideous Websites.

A beautiful website can be a thing of art. But too many websites are poorly designed and will make visitors cringe. Not only that, but load times are much higher than the recommended 2 seconds, which will cost you customers. Particularly mobile customers.

How to avoid this mistake:

Your website is your calling card on the web, so don't leave visitors with a bad impression. Try these ways to influence emotion with your design to increase sales, and keep visitors coming back. If you don't feel comfortable building your own website, get the professionals (like us!) to do it for you.


We hope you have a Halloween filled with treats.

Have you seen other scary internet marketing mistakes?  Share them in the comments below!



 Lindsey is the Vice President of Communications for ApogeeINVENT, and is the social media voice and blogger for the company. Follow her on Twitter or connect with her on Google+

Douglas 5 years ago
Great article here!
Udit Khanna 6 years ago
Information provided on this blog is very much relevant. Keep on updating such information so that people do not make any mistakes.